TT logo
You are viewing a low-graphics version of this page. Click the headline to view full version:

Gender discrimination in job adverts

Legality of advertising for females only

Toytown Germany > Discussion forum > Germany-wide > Legal
Johnny English
QUOTE (JonEuro @ Nov 28 2006, 5:00 pm) *
At the Euro Youth Hotel we are currently looking for two female bar staff to work evenings at our lively hostel bar. This is to replace two existing female employees that will be leaving us shortly.

Is this not illegal these days?

Interestingly under European Law I am allowed to advertise for FEMALE only staff for the lingerie business, because of the very specialist fact that they will be handling naked women, but does this apply to bar staff as well?
perdido
Maybe maybe not. I know that in the states the company I worked for would ask for applicants without mentioning them to be female. The company would place the applicants that were non female in a file for later. You see the company had to meet a requirement of female as well as minority employees without advertising for such. It was a tricky line to walk but the company did it. Maybe the same here.
cinzia
I don't think it's illegal here. I've seen lots of adverts for regular bar and restaurant staff that specify female.
MadAxeMurderer
What about the models themselves?

Presumably its even more important to you that the models are female, than that the handlers are female.
Kay
QUOTE (cinzia @ Nov 28 2006, 5:54 pm) *
I don't think it's illegal here. I've seen lots of adverts for regular bar and restaurant staff that specify female.

That doesn't mean such adverts are legal, though. Many employers also specify a "preferred" age in their job adverts (25-35, for instance) although AFAIK discriminating on the basis of age is against EU law.
MonksTown
I'd guess illegal.
Johnny English
http://www.eoc.org.uk/default.aspx?page=15643

As it is clearly illegal in the UK, just surprised this is not also the case here in Germany?
Johnny English
On the lingerie modelling and fitting side it is covered by these exceptions:

It is lawful to discriminate in recruitment, training, promotion and transfer in a job for which the sex of a worker is a genuine occupational qualification (GOQ). GOQs are interpreted very narrowly by the courts and can only be claimed where the work:

is restricted to one sex for reasons of physiology or authenticity
is restricted to one sex to preserve privacy and decency
Wheel
According to the EU's website it's illegal all over the Union (ref. Directive 2002/73).

QUOTE
Employers must not discriminate between men and women when recruiting workers. So, for instance, job advertising biased in favour of one sex is contrary to Community law.

However, different treatment is exceptionally permitted, under certain conditions where the gender of the workers is an essential factor in the job. If it is objectively proven that only workers of one sex can perform all the tasks related to the job, then the employer is allowed to recruit only men or only women for that job.

My German's not good enough to check for applicable laws, but it's possible that the directive hasn't been implemented here, or that it simply isn't enforced. The only country which implements and enforces every directive seems to be the UK.
Johnny English
Just amused that TT is normally so PC, and the mods go bananas if you post a picture of someone with their arm in the air - but allow illegal job adverts.

If I owned a bar, I would employ crumpet as well, just would be more careful when running recruitment adverts.
Yeti
Crumpet is so sexist, you have to say totty now.
Owain Glyndwr
I prefer the gender-neutral term "eye candy", borrowed from our north American cousins.
sarabyrd
FYI, Antidiskriminierungsgesetz
Crawlie
I bet Hooters must have a nightmare trying to recruit in Germany then...

"Waiters/Waitresses required in our busy restaurant. Must have a great personality, presentable, be able to work in a fast-paced environment. Oh, huge tits a must."
Yeti
Totty isn't neutral ?
Crawlie
I suppose it could be
Small Town Boy
To be honest, if the guy wants a woman working there then he's going to choose a woman, regardless of how many men apply. This just saves all the guys from wasting their time.
perdido
What if he has "man cans"?
Qwertz
QUOTE (Haendeline @ Aug 1 2008, 1:16 pm) *
Nice female English teacher wanted for a nursery-school teacher in Munich. The assignment is part of a government-subsidized qualification course. 4 teaching units of 45 minutes per week (payment EUR 25,- per teaching unit).
Please contact haendeline@gmx.de for further details.

There's another one.
You are viewing a low fidelity version of this page. Click to view the full page.